Add Your Review

Thanks for visiting Meatball Mafia. We'd love to have your feedback!

Old Hilliard - Center Street Market

Type to search our menu...

You are submitting your information to Meatball Mafia and Popmenu, which powers this site and is sponsoring this giveaway. Popmenu's and apply.

Our Latest Reviews

Kim about 1 month ago

Crumbled Sausage Pizza

Been a minute since I have been in. Just picked up a sausage pizza and peppers in oil ( it is a Youngstown thing), just as good as always!! No matter when I order the quality is the same and it is always delicious!! Thanks for bringing a taste of Youngstown to Hilliard!

Gena Boyd about 2 months ago

Big Fat Antnee

Amazing flavor. Very good pizza

Jlapp75 2 months ago

Pepperoni Pizza

I moved to Columbus 7 years ago from Youngstown and really missed pizza and food from back home. This pizza is one that would be successful in Youngstown, absolutely delicious. Almost reminded me of Angelo's on the southside of the Yo. Keep killing it!

Jessterlecky 3 months ago

Pepperoni Pizza

My husband and I are from Youngstown and have pretty much gone EVERYWHERE in Columbus to try and find something close to Y-town pizza. Meatball Mafia is the BEST pizza around. We love it!

Mstall0515 5 months ago

Brier Hill Pizza (St. Anthony's Style)

As a Youngstown native, this pizza brought a tear to my eye. Thank you for bringing the authentic Brier Hill experience to Columbus! Delicious as it was in my childhood

Merrowmj about 2 months ago

Pepperoni Pizza

This is hands down the best pizza we've had in a long time. Thick but pillowy crust, delicious sauce and cheesy - along with crispy thin pepp. We can't wait to go back and try the rest!

Sarakmehaffey 2 months ago

Cheese Pizza

I am from Texas and my son is a freshman at Ohio State who LOVES pizza. This is by far the best pizza we've found anywhere close to the university. The sauce is just amazing. We go multiple times every visit and I wish it was closer to campus. Try it! You won't be disappointed.

Miamibuckeye1072 2 months ago

James A. Traficant (AKA The Jim Bowl)

Throughly enjoyed the Jimmy T! Delicious, decadent meatballs in a tasty sauce over top of a traditional Italian pasta salad. An innovative but crazy dish that works... kind of like ol' Jim!

Colleen 4 months ago

White Pizza (Youngstown Style)

Fantastic pizza, just like home taste with all of the right ingredients! We highly recommend Meatball Mafia to all our friends., especially the transplants from the old neighborhood!

Taltos23 5 months ago

The Vindicator

Never been to Youngstown but I get it now...this thing was awesome. Great crunch, nice amount of heat but doesn't overpower a good flavor from everything else. The Mafia aren't just about meatballs, they got this pizza thing locked down too.


February 2023:
Coming soon

January 2023:
Justine, Blue Sky Cafe
Fletcher, NC

December 2022:
Kelly, Cookies Country Chicken
Seattle, WA

November 2022:
Laney, Archie Moore's
New Haven, CT

October 2022:
Melissa, Noble Crust
St. Pete, FL

September 2022:
Ben, Cinn City
Lynchburg, VA

August 2022:
Rebecca, Udder Delight
Cranston, RI

July 2022:
Randolph, Turkey Leg Hut
Houston, TX

June 2022:
Lawrence, O'Ya Cantina
Chapel Hill, NC

May 2022:
David, Grillsmith
Sarasota, FL

April 2022:
Katie, Jelly Cafe
Denver, CO

March 2022:
Marny, PPC Italian Restaurant
Plaistow, NH

February 2022:
Teresa, Black Angus
Vancouver, BC

January 2022:
Deirdre, White Pie
Colorado Springs, CO

December 2021:
Camille, Patsy's Roadhouse
Hopewell Junction, NY

November 2021:
Sherry, Riverpark Pub and Eatery
Parkville, MO

October 2021:
Stephanie, Hightopps Backstage Grille
Timonium, MD

September 2021:
Megan, Scratch Kitchen & Taproom
Apex, NC

August 2021:
Jerome, Taste of Soul by Ms. Nancy
Burlington, NJ

July 2021:
The Great Greek, NV

June 2021:
Sylvia, Urth Caffé
Los Angeles, CA 

May 2021:
Amber, Haute Dogs and Fries
Alexandria, VA

April 2021:
Travis, El Monumento
Georgetown, TX

March 2021:
Susan, Alden Park
Plymouth, MA

February 2021:
Leilani, Hon Machi Korean BBQ
San Antonio, TX

January 2021:
Goodrich Seafood & Oyster House

December 2020:
Hallee, Pizza Sociale
Los Angeles, CA

November 2020:
Barbara, PPC Italian Restaurant
Plaistow, NH

October 2020:
Charn, Vitaly
Costa Mesa, CA

September 2020:
Carol, Stroud's BBQ
Daytona Beach Shores, FL

August 2020:
Jo-El, Mick's All American
Mount Joy, PA 

July 2020:
Bronson, Los Dos Potrillos 

June 2020:
Elish, Crump's Landing
Homosassa, FL

May 2020:
Carlson, Papi Grande's Mexican
Amherst, NY

April 2020:
Sommer, Little Calf Creamery 
Thousand Oaks, CA

March 2020:
Theresa, Woody's Crab House
North East, MD

February 2020:
Maria, The Rustik Fork
Riverside, CA

January 2020:
Marsha, Stefano's Restaurant
Florence, SC

December 2019:
Alma, Karai Ramen Bistro
Jacksonville, FL

November 2019:
Courtney, Axe & Arrow
Seattle, WA

October 2019:
Andy, Backwoods Brewing Co.
Portland, OR

September 2019:
Amanda, Home Restaurant
Los Angeles, CA

August 2019:
Jennifer, Mark's City Grill
Columbus, GA

July 2019:
Rebecca, Frank Gourmet
Buffalo, NY

June 2019:
Donna, Dino's Sports Bar
Cape Cod, MA

May 2019:
Karen, This Little Pig
Amherst, NY

April 2019:
Alicia, Plant Based Pizzeria
Atlanta, GA