Skip to main contentWebsite Accessibility Assistance

Welcome To The Mafia

We're two Italian American brothers originally from the greatest Italian American place on Earth; Youngstown, Ohio. After 14 years of living in Columbus, I couldn't help but miss the flavors of my beloved Youngstown!

We started as a food truck in 2016, and in 2020 opened our first location inside the Center Street Market in Hilliard, Ohio. Recently we opened a bar that features the Meatball Mafia in its kitchen, Missing Jimmy's, in Dublin, Ohio. 
Leave a Review

Cheese Garlic Bread

Very good!

Charlotte

Pesto Pasta Salad

Soooooo good!

Charlotte

Large Meatball Bowl

I am a Youngstown native & had to give this place a try when I was in the area. Did not disappoint absolutely phenomenal, delicious fast and friendly service too! Give this place a try!

Monkeygrl3169

Opens in a new windowOpens an external siteOpens an external site in a new window